Choosing a solver

Start with the least costly method that supports both your physics and your desired output. The table lists supported combinations. All seven solver families return solution objects. Hover a column header for what that solver is. Hover the ℹ️ icon next to a geometry for its caveats, or follow a linked geometry name to the page covering it.

Boundary condition Modal T-matrix Kirchhoff FEM BEM MFS Fourier
Rigid Sphere
Spheroid
Cylinder ℹ️
Sphere
Spheroid
Cylinder ℹ️
Arbitrary ℹ️
Sphere ℹ️
Spheroid ℹ️
Cylinder ℹ️
Sphere ℹ️
Spheroid ℹ️
Cylinder ℹ️
Arbitrary ℹ️
Sphere ℹ️
Spheroid ℹ️
Cylinder ℹ️
Sphere
Spheroid
Irregular ℹ️
Locally reacting (impedance) Sphere ℹ️ Sphere ℹ️
Pressure-release Sphere
Spheroid
Cylinder ℹ️
Sphere
Spheroid
Cylinder ℹ️
Arbitrary ℹ️
Sphere ℹ️
Spheroid ℹ️
Cylinder ℹ️
Sphere ℹ️
Spheroid ℹ️
Cylinder ℹ️
Arbitrary ℹ️
Sphere ℹ️
Spheroid ℹ️
Cylinder ℹ️
Sphere
Spheroid
Irregular ℹ️
Fluid or gas interior Sphere
Spheroid
Cylinder ℹ️
Sphere
Spheroid
Cylinder ℹ️
Arbitrary ℹ️
Sphere ℹ️
Spheroid ℹ️
Cylinder ℹ️
Sphere ℹ️
Spheroid ℹ️
Cylinder ℹ️
Arbitrary ℹ️
Sphere ℹ️
Spheroid ℹ️
Cylinder ℹ️
Sphere
Spheroid
Irregular ℹ️
Solid elastic Sphere
Cylinder ℹ️
Spheroid ℹ️ Sphere ℹ️
Spheroid ℹ️
Cylinder ℹ️
Elastic shell, fluid interior Sphere
Cylinder ℹ️
Spheroid ℹ️ Sphere ℹ️
Spheroid ℹ️
Cylinder ℹ️
Elastic shell, empty interior Spheroid ℹ️ Sphere ℹ️
Spheroid ℹ️
Fluid shell, fluid or vacuum interior Sphere Sphere ℹ️ Sphere ℹ️ Sphere ℹ️
Viscoelastic layered shell, fluid interior Sphere ℹ️
Coupled fluid regions, nested or disjoint Sphere ℹ️ Sphere ℹ️
Spheroid ℹ️
Arbitrary ℹ️
Planar free surface or seafloor Sphere ℹ️
Spheroid ℹ️

Choosing by question

  • Use sphere or spheroid modal methods as analytical references, while checking series convergence and special-function conditioning.
  • Use Kirchhoff to explore physical-optics behavior. A numerically converged surface integral does not establish validity of physical optics at low frequency.
  • Use FEM or BEM when checking analytical reductions, geometry discretization, or interface coupling. Compare against a canonical case first. Full 3D volume FEM is the general-purpose reference for elastic and shelled spheres and spheroids.
  • Use MFS when source placement is well controlled and its supported geometry suits the problem.
  • Use BEM surface results for repeated observation-angle queries. Radial FEM spheres and cylinders provide complex backscatter; meridian FEM cylinders and spheroids also provide complex amplitudes at arbitrary bistatic angles.
  • Use Fourier matching for a smooth irregular body of revolution between the canonical (sphere/spheroid) and general numerical (BEM/MFS/FEM) solvers. See Fourier matching.

See BEM and MFS for the underlying boundary integral and source-fitting theory.